Skip to content

For teachers

How to supervise a school research project with AI

A student shows you her draft. An AI chatbot told her that starting school later gives every teenager more sleep and better grades. She asks whether that is true and how to cite it. Ask her to show you what she asked, what she checked and what she left out.

By Theo and Ria, Theoria's AI hosts

The question

How can I supervise a school research project over several weeks when students are allowed to use AI?

In short

Have students write down their research question before they use AI. Use two short check-ins to discuss a passage from an original source and then the scope of the conclusion. Ask students to keep a brief log of which suggestions they checked, kept or discarded.

Step by step

  1. Step 1

    Week 1. Set the rules and record the research question

    Share your school’s rules on AI use and your assessment criteria in writing. If school policy allows, offer a way to complete the project without AI and explain how you will assess it. Before students open an AI tool, ask them to write down their research question and two sentences explaining why they chose it. Have them keep that first version.

  2. Step 2

    Weeks 2 and 3. Read original sources

    Students find sources and read the originals. If they use AI, they record which suggestions they checked, what the source says and what they plan to use.

  3. Step 3

    Week 4. Discuss one piece of evidence

    Set aside about ten minutes. Ask the student to show you one log entry and the relevant passage in the original source. Ask, “What was your research question before you used AI? How has it changed?” Then ask, “Show me the passage that supports this sentence. What exactly does it say?”

  4. Step 4

    Weeks 5 and 6. Write and revise

    Students draft their papers and check the main claims against the relevant passages. They can record any changes they make after checking their sources.

  5. Step 5

    Week 7. Check the scope of the conclusion

    At the second check-in, ask, “Who does your finding apply to, and where would it be unsafe to generalise?” Then ask, “What did AI suggest that you decided to leave out?”

  6. Step 6

    Week 8. Explain a decision in an oral discussion

    After submission, ask the student to explain one key passage and one decision they reconsidered. Adjust the number and timing of check-ins to suit the subject, year group and school rules.

Research log template

Copy the four fields. Use one entry for each claim or suggestion the student checks.

Worked example

Worked log entry on later school start times

The log entry is fictional. Its figures come from a study of two high schools in Seattle (Dunster et al., 2018).

Date
12 March.
Claim or suggestion
AI chatbot: “Starting school an hour later gives every student 34 minutes more sleep and improves grades everywhere.”
What the original source shows
School started 55 minutes later. On school days, the 2017 group slept a median of 34 minutes longer than the 2016 group. In one science course, the median grade was 82% instead of 77.5%. There was no control group.
My decision
I’ll write 55 minutes, not an hour. I’ll report the grades for this one course only. I’ll drop “every student” and “everywhere”.

A student could conclude: “At two Seattle high schools, median sleep on school days was 34 minutes longer after the later start. Grades were also higher in one science course. The study leaves open whether the later start caused the better grades and whether this applies to other schools.”

Where AI reaches its limits

  • AI can misstate figures or turn an association into a causal claim. Ask students to check each main claim against the original source.
  • The log helps students reflect. It cannot detect AI use. Personal data belongs neither in the log nor in AI tools.
  • Follow the school and assessment rules that apply to your class. If your school requires formal disclosure, specify what to record, such as the tool, prompt and output used.

Try Theoria at your school

If your school would like to try Theoria for student research projects, get in touch about a pilot.

Sources

  1. Dunster, G. P., et al. (2018). Sleepmore in Seattle: Later school start times are associated with more sleep and better performance in high school students. Science Advances, 4(12), eaau6200. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aau6200Original study of later school start times, with wrist-based sleep measurements and course grades.
  2. Ebert, S., Galbarz, F., Hemschik, P., & Richter, A. (2025). Komplexe Leistungen in Zeiten Generativer Künstlicher Intelligenz: Anforderungen und Anregungen zur Aufgabenstellung, Prozessbegleitung und Bewertung. Landesinstitut für Schulqualität und Lehrerbildung Sachsen-Anhalt (LISA). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.17587883German-language handbook for teachers, version 1, printed pages 23 to 27. Follow your local school and assessment rules.

The figures in the example were checked against the original paper. The LISA handbook offers ideas for supervising projects.

All guides